← All guides

Receiving a Container of Marble or Granite: Unloading, Checks and Damage Claims

Before the seal is cut, match the container and seal numbers to the bill of lading and photograph both, then write any damage on the delivery receipt before you sign it: a clean receipt is treated as evidence that the goods arrived as described. Who pays for broken slabs depends on the Incoterm and the policy behind it. Under FOB, FCA or EXW you insured the voyage and you claim; under CIF the seller bought the policy in your favour, but the default Institute Cargo Clauses (C) do not cover breakage in handling, so the cover has to be checked before the ship sails, not after the doors open.

Before the doors open: seal, container number and delivery receipt

Start with the paperwork, not the stone. The container number and the seal number are on the bill of lading and usually on the packing list; read both off the box before anyone touches the seal. Photograph the seal in place, close enough to read the number, and the outside of the container from several angles, including dents, holes or any sign the doors were forced. A broken or mismatched seal at arrival is among the strongest evidence in a disputed cargo claim, so if the seal is missing or the number is wrong, stop and call your forwarder and insurer before the doors are opened.

The delivery receipt (proof of delivery, or the interchange report at a depot) is the second document that decides a claim. Write any visible damage or shortage on it before the driver leaves and before you sign, naming what you saw: a split bundle, a shifted A-frame, water on the floor. A receipt signed clean is the usual reason a later claim against the carrier fails, and the carriage rules below explain why.

Unloading slabs from bundles and A-frames

Slabs leave Egypt standing on edge, in closed wooden bundles blocked to the container floor or strapped to A-frames; the formats and weights are in how many slabs fit in a 20ft container. The format decides the unloading method, so the supplier should know before packing whether you have a crane, a forklift with a slab boom and clamp, or only forks.

OSHA's safety bulletin on handling granite and marble slabs counts 46 deaths in the United States between 1984 and 2006, most involving slabs shifting inside containers or during unloading with a forklift boom. Its recommendations are the ones to give the yard crew: remove the timber bracing in a sequence that leaves the remaining slabs supported; raise a boom load only as far as needed to clear the floor; use scissor clamps only on sound stone without open seams or cracks, which matters for fissured limestones such as Galala and Sunny; put a tag line on slabs hanging from a crane; and keep everyone out of the fall shadow, the strip either side of a slab where it would land if it toppled.

For A-frames, WorkSafe Victoria prefers an overhead crane, with a forklift as the fallback on level ground, load kept low, reversing so the slab moves away from the workers. Leave the frame's uprights in place, take slabs alternately from each side so the frame stays balanced, check the wind before lifting outdoors, and confirm nobody is in the fall shadow before any strap is released. Slabs go straight from the container into a rack or A-frame, on edge with the polished face protected, not onto the floor.

Checking the delivery against the packing list

Count bundles first, then slabs within each bundle, against the packing list, and check that the numbers written on the slab edges match the pre-shipment photographs you approved. The photo set described in how to inspect slabs before shipment is what makes this possible: if every slab was photographed with its number and a tape in the frame, a missing or substituted slab shows up in minutes. Spot-check thickness with a caliper on slabs from different bundles against the tolerance in your order.

For tiles, open crates from more than one shade lot rather than only the ones nearest the door, and compare the lot marking on the crate with the sorting you agreed. How many crates to open depends on the order size and on whether a pre-shipment inspection already sampled them; the inspection guide covers sampling plans and the purchase order wording. Shortages and substitutions go on the delivery receipt too, with the same photographs as damage.

Documenting damage and the time limits for notice

Photograph damaged bundles where they stand, bundle number legible, before anything is moved, then the individual slabs once they are out. Keep the packing, straps, broken pieces and seal until the insurer or surveyor says otherwise, and keep damaged slabs apart from sound ones.

The carriage rules set the clock. Under the Hague-Visby Rules, unless written notice of the loss or damage and its general nature is given to the carrier or its agent at the port of discharge before or at the time the goods are removed, or within three days if the damage is not apparent, removal is prima facie evidence that the carrier delivered the goods as described in the bill of lading. Written notice is not needed where the goods were jointly surveyed on receipt, and suit against the carrier must be brought within one year of delivery. The United Kingdom schedules these rules in its Carriage of Goods by Sea Act 1971; other countries apply the Hague, Hague-Visby or Hamburg regimes with their own variations, and the bill of lading's terms say which applies. A US cargo claims guide gives the same three-day written notice for ocean carriers and adds that notice to the carrier protects the insurer's right of recovery, which is why an insurer will ask whether you sent it.

Notify the insurer at the same time and ask for a surveyor straight away; insurers usually appoint and pay the surveyor. Which insurer follows the Incoterm. Under EXW, FCA and FOB each party insures its own leg, so the sea transit is yours to insure and yours to claim. Under CIF the seller must insure in favour of the buyer, and the CIF rule requires that insurance to be such that the buyer, or anyone else with an insurable interest in the goods, can claim directly from the insurer; the seller hands over the policy or a certificate for that purpose. Risk still passed to you when the stone went on board in Egypt, so a CIF seller is not liable for the transit damage itself. The Incoterms are covered in how to import marble from Egypt.

What Institute Cargo Clauses (C) cover, and what they do not

The Institute Cargo Clauses (C) of 1 January 2009 cover loss or damage reasonably attributable to fire or explosion; the vessel being stranded, grounded, sunk or capsized; overturning or derailment of a land conveyance; collision or contact with an external object other than water; discharge of cargo at a port of distress; and loss or damage caused by general average sacrifice or jettison. That is the whole list. The Institute Cargo Clauses (A) cover all risks of loss of or damage to the insured goods except as excluded by clauses 4 to 7. An insurer's comparison table of the three sets marks loss or damage during loading and discharge, theft and any other physical loss not specified as outside (B) and (C), and entry of sea water as outside (C).

For stone, that means a slab that cracks because a bundle was dropped at the terminal, or because the load shifted in heavy weather, is not a named peril under (C). Incoterms 2020 keep (C) as the default a CIF seller must buy, and the ICC describes it as minimum cover, so a CIF quotation that says nothing about the clauses leaves ordinary breakage uninsured. Ask for (A) in the quotation, or insure the shipment yourself and buy on FOB or CFR; an insurer's Incoterms summary gives a buyer exactly those two options.

Two further clauses apply even under (A). Exclusion 4.3 removes loss caused by insufficiency or unsuitability of packing to withstand the ordinary incidents of the transit, where the packing was done by the assured or their employees or before the insurance attached, and packing is defined to include stowage in a container. Slabs that broke because the bundle was badly built or badly blocked can therefore fall outside the policy and back onto the supplier. The transit clause ends cover on unloading at the final warehouse or, at the latest, 60 days after discharge from the ship, so a container left standing at the port or in the yard is not insured indefinitely.

Supplier claim or insurance claim?

Sort the damage into two kinds before writing to anyone. Transit damage is a bundle that fell, a frame that tipped, water through a holed roof: the carrier and the cargo insurer are the parties, and the evidence is the receipt notes, the seal photos and the survey. Packing and quality damage is slabs cracked along fissures with the bundle intact, straps cut into the edges, mesh backing lifted, thickness out of tolerance or a shade that differs from the approved photos: that is a conversation with the supplier, and under FOB or CIF it is the only basis for one, because the seller's responsibility for the voyage ended on board.

A supplier will ask for the same file the insurer does, matched to the packing list: the damaged slab and bundle numbers, a photograph of each with the number visible, the pre-shipment photographs of the same slabs, the surveyor's report where there is one, and the delivery receipt. The faster that file arrives, the less room there is to argue that the damage happened in your yard. What the supplier then owes depends on what the order said: the purchase order points in the inspection guide include what happens with rejected pieces, whether replacement, credit or discount. If the balance was paid against numbered photos before shipment, as that guide suggests, the dispute is confined to the pieces that differ from those photos.

Storage and handover to the installer

Keep each shade lot together as it came out of the container and give the installer a plan that lays one lot per room or elevation; how far Egyptian beiges and greys move between blocks is in the marble types guide. Store slabs on edge under cover, dry, with timber between the stone and any steel: the inspection guide lists rust marks from strapping and wet storage among the defects buyers reject.

Tell the installer the stone's name and type, because it changes the adhesive. Most Egyptian marbles are limestones, often light and somewhat translucent, and a stone-trade tiling guide recommends a white cement-based adhesive for light-coloured stone so that a dark bed does not show through; it adds that most staining in stone tiling comes from moisture in the adhesive getting into the tile, that rapid-drying adhesives, which take up their free water as they harden, reduce that risk, and that blob fixing invites both problems. Cleaning and sealing afterwards are in sealing and caring for Egyptian limestone. For granites such as New Halayeb and Halayeb the adhesive colour matters less, but the shade-lot discipline is the same.

If you want to agree before shipment how bundles and slabs are numbered, photographed and listed so that the check at your yard matches the packing list line by line, contact us.

Stones in this guide

Related guides

Need sizes, finishes or a quote? Contact us.